The green links below add additional plants to the comparison table. Blue links lead to other Web sites.
enable glossary links

brittlebush

Habit Annuals, perennials, subshrubs, or shrubs, (3–)10–200(–400+) [2500+] cm. Perennials, subshrubs, or shrubs (10–)30–150 cm.
Stems

erect, usually branched from bases, often throughout (scapiform in E. nutans and E. scaposa).

Leaves

usually cauline, sometimes mostly basal, or basal and cauline; opposite, alternate, or both;

petiolate or sessile;

blades cordate, deltate, elliptic, lanceolate, linear, rhombic, orbiculate, or ovate (and intermediate shapes), often 1(–2+)-palmately or -pinnately lobed, ultimate margins entire or toothed, faces glabrous or hairy (often hispid or scabrous), often gland-dotted or stipitate-glandular.

usually cauline, sometimes basal (E. nutans and E. scaposa); alternate (usually drought-deciduous);

petiolate (obscurely in E. scaposa);

blades (1- or 3-nerved) mostly deltate, lanceolate, rhombic, or ovate (narrowly oblanceolate to linear in E. scaposa), bases broadly to narrowly cuneate, margins usually entire, rarely toothed, face glabrous or canescent, hirtellous, scabrellous, strigose, or tomentose, often gland-dotted as well.

Involucres

cylindric, or campanulate to hemispheric or broader, or rotate.

± hemispheric or broader, 4–22 mm diam.

Receptacles

convex, conic, or flat, paleate (paleae usually falling, oblong to linear, herbaceous to chartaceous or scarious, usually conduplicate).

flat or convex, paleate (paleae ± conduplicate, folded around and falling with cypselae).

Ray florets

usually (1–)3–40+, sometimes 0, usually pistillate and fertile, sometimes styliferous and sterile, or neuter;

corollas usually yellow to orange, sometimes pink to purple, red, brown, or white (sometimes sessile, persistent, and becoming papery, e.g., in Heliopsis, Sanvitalia, and Zinnia).

0 or 8–25(–40), neuter;

corollas yellow.

Disc florets

4–200+, bisexual and fertile, or functionally staminate;

corollas usually yellow to orange, sometimes brown, greenish, maroon, pink, purple, or red, rarely white or whitish, tubes shorter to longer than campanulate, cylindric, or funnelform throats, lobes (4–)5, deltate to lanceolate (usually equal);

anther thecae usually dark (collars not continuous around filaments);

stigmatic papillae usually continuous, sometimes none, rarely in 2 lines.

80–100(–200+), bisexual, fertile;

corollas yellow or brown-purple, tubes shorter than to equaling abruptly expanded throats, lobes 5, triangular.

Phyllaries

persistent or falling, usually 8–40+ in 2–4+ series, usually distinct, usually lanceolate, linear, orbiculate, or ovate, subequal or unequal (outer usually shorter, rarely longer, than inner).

persistent, 18–30(–50+) in 2–3+ series (subequal to unequal, outer shorter).

Calyculi

0.

Heads

usually radiate, sometimes discoid, borne singly or in cymiform, corymbiform, paniculiform, racemiform, or spiciform arrays.

radiate or discoid, borne singly or in ± paniculiform arrays (peduncles usually longer than involucres).

Cypselae

obpyramidal or prismatic (3–4-angled), or terete to ovoid, or strongly compressed or flattened and ± orbiculate to obovate or cuneate (lengths seldom more than 2 times diams.), sometimes ribbed, sometimes winged, glabrous or hairy;

pappi usually persistent, sometimes fragile or readily falling, usually of scales, sometimes of bristles or bristlelike awns or coroniform, rarely of awns or 0.

strongly compressed, obovate to cuneate (margins ciliate, apices usually ± notched except in E. scaposa, faces usually glabrous except in E. scaposa);

pappi usually 0, sometimes readily falling or persistent, of 2 bristlelike awns.

x

= 18.

Asteraceae tribe Heliantheae subtribe Ecliptinae

Encelia

Distribution
Mostly subtropical and warm-temperate North America; especially arid areas; also in the Old World
from USDA
sw United States; Mexico; South America
[BONAP county map]
Discussion

Genera 75, species 600 (31 genera, 124 species, including 4 hybrids, in the flora).

The circumscription of Ecliptinae adopted by H. Robinson (1981) and followed here differs from the treatment by P. O. Karis and O. Ryding (1994), who placed Eclipta as unassigned to a subtribe and placed Echinacea in Rudbeckiinae, Acmella, Heliopsis, Sanvitalia, and Zinnia in Zinniinae, Berlandiera, Chrysogonum, Engelmannia, Lindheimera, and Silphium in Engelmanniinae, and Balsamorhiza (including Agnorhiza), Borrichia, Calyptocarpus, Encelia, Enceliopsis, Flourensia, Geraea, Helianthella, Jefea, Lasianthaea, Melanthera, Pascalia, Phoebanthus, Sphagneticola, Synedrella, Verbesina, Wedelia, and Wyethia (including Scabrethia) in Verbesininae. Based on studies of chloroplast DNA sequences, J. L. Panero (2005) placed Encelia, Enceliopsis, Flourensia, Geraea, and Helianthella together in Enceliinae and Acmella in Spilanthinae, indicating a sister relationship between Spilanthinae and traditionally circumscribed Zinniinae.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Species 13 or 14 (8 in the flora).

Encelias commonly hybridize, especially in disturbed areas: Encelia farinosa × E. frutescens is common; E. farinosa × E. californica, E. farinosa × E. actoni, E. actoni × E. frutescens, E. frutescens × E. virginensis, and E. farinosa × Geraea canescens have been reported.

(Discussion copyrighted by Flora of North America; reprinted with permission.)

Key
1. Ray florets usually 5–21 (more in "double" cultivars), sometimes 0 (in Zinnia anomala, subshrubs or shrublets to 12 cm, leaves linear, Texas), corollas usually yellow to orange, sometimes purple, red, or whitish (usually persistent, sessile, becoming papery)
→ 2
1. Ray florets usually (2–)5–35, sometimes 0, corollas usually yellow to orange, sometimes white (seldom sessile, laminae usually borne on tubes, never persistent and becoming papery)
→ 4
2. Leaf margins serrate to coarsely toothed
Heliopsis
2. Leaf margins entire
→ 3
3. Leaves petiolate or sessile; cypselae ± terete or obscurely 3–4-angled to compressed or flattened (all usually tuberculate and usually bearing uncinate hairs, none, some,or all in each head winged)
Sanvitalia
3. Leaves sessile; cypselae 3-angled or flattened (none with uncinate hairs, none winged)
Zinnia
4. Disc florets functionally staminate (only ray florets produce cypselae)
→ 5
4. Disc florets bisexual, fertile
→ 9
5. Phyllaries 8–10 in 2 series
→ 6
5. Phyllaries 12–45+ in (2–)3–4 series
→ 7
6. Perennials; leaves opposite, petiolate, margins crenate
Chrysogonum
6. Annuals; leaves mostly alternate (distal sometimes opposite), ± sessile, margins coarsely toothed (mostly distal 1/2)
Lindheimera
7. Ray florets 8–35 (in 1–3 series); cypselae (shed alone without accessory structures)
Silphium
7. Ray florets usually (2–)8(–13); cypselae (each shed together with subtending phyllary and 2–4 adjacent paleae and disc florets)
→ 8
8. Phyllaries usually 14–22 in 2–3 series (broadly obovate to orbiculate, without linear appendages); ray corollas pale yellow to orange-yellow (abaxially red to maroon or with greenish or red to maroon veins)
Berlandiera
8. Phyllaries 18–24+ in ± 3 series (at least outer with relatively short, expanded, indurate bases and longer, linear, herbaceous tips); ray corollasyellow (without notably colored veins)
Engelmannia
9. Leaves mostly basal, or basal and cauline, or cauline, mostly alternate
→ 10
9. Leaves mostly cauline, mostly opposite
→ 21
10. Cypselae prismatic, or nearly so, 3–4-angled
→ 11
10. Cypselae compressed to flattened
→ 15
11. Ray florets usually 8–21 (corollas mostly pink, red, purple, or white, yellow in E. paradoxa var. paradoxa, laminae often drooping or reflexed);receptacles mostly conic (heights often 2+ times diams.)
Echinacea
11. Ray florets (1–)5–25+ (corollas yellow or orange, laminae not drooping or reflexed), sometimes 0; receptacles flat to convex
→ 12
12. Leaves mostly basal (cauline usually notably smaller than basal); pappi 0
Balsamorhiza
12. Leaves basal and cauline, or mostly cauline; pappi usually coroniform, sometimes of 1–4+ scales or 0
→ 13
13. Leaves mostly cauline (blades narrowly oblong to linear, 5–25 mmwide)
Scabrethia
13. Leaves basal and cauline, or mostly cauline (blades mostly 30–120 mm wide)
→ 14
14. Leaves mostly elliptic, lanceolate, or oblong (basal and cauline, basal usually notably larger than cauline, cauline mostly sessile)
Wyethia
14. Leaves mostly orbiculate, ovate, or rounded-deltate (mostly cauline, mostly petiolate, proximal and distal usually ± similar)
Agnorhiza
15. Cypselae winged; pappi persistent, of 2(–3) scales (scales often aristate or subulate, without additional scales)
Verbesina
15. Cypselae sometimes thin-edged (margins sometimes ciliate or corky-thickened, never truly winged); pappi usually of (1–)2, subulate scales or bristlelike awns plus 2–4+ shorter scales, sometimes 0 (rarely of 2–3 aristate scales without additional scales)
→ 16
16. Perennials (scapiform); leaves all or mostly basal; involucres 20–30+ mm diam
Enceliopsis
16. Perennials (rarely scapiform), subshrubs, or shrubs; leaves usually cauline, sometimes basal and cauline; involucres 4–30 mm diam
→ 17
17. Perennials (rhizomatous); leaves linear to filiform
Phoebanthus
17. Perennials or shrubs (not rhizomatous); leaves mostly deltate, elliptic, lanceolate, or ovate (and most intermediate shapes, not linear to filiform)
→ 18
18. Ray florets 8–21, pistillate and fertile
Helianthella
18. Ray florets 0 or 8–40, neuter, or styliferous and sterile
→ 19
19. Subshrubs or shrubs (glabrous or ± scabrellous, usually vernicose); phyllaries 12–40 in 2–4+ series (subequal or unequal, outer longer)
Flourensia
19. Annuals, perennials, or shrubs (glabrous or canescent, hirtellous, scabrellous, strigose, or tomentose, often gland-dotted or glandular-puberulent to stipitate-glandular, seldom vernicose); phyllaries 18–30(–50+) in 2–3+ series (subequal or unequal, outer shorter)
→ 20
20. Perennials (E. nutans), subshrubs, or shrubs; pappi usually 0, sometimes fragile, of 2 weak, villous scales
Encelia
20. Annuals or perennials; pappi usually persistent, of 2 subulate scales
Geraea
21. Heads discoid (corollas white or whitish); pappi 0, or readily falling, of 2–12 barbellate bristles or awns
Melanthera
21. Heads radiate or discoid (corollas seldom white or whitish); pappi 0, or usually persistent and coroniform or cyathiform (each an erose, fimbriate, or lacerate cup, with or without additional awns or bristles, borne on rostrums), or of 2–4+ awns, bristles, and/or scales
→ 22
22. Pappi usually coroniform or cyathiform (cypselae often rostrate, each with apical boss or neck), sometimes 0 (prostrate perennials)
→ 23
22. Pappi usually of 2–4+ awns, bristles, and/or scales (not cyathiform, cypselae not rostrate), sometimes coroniform or 0 (not prostrate perennials)
→ 24
23. Subshrubs or shrubs (erect); cypselae (some or all) strongly compressed, nota-bly winged
Wedelia
23. Perennials (prostrate); cypselae strongly biconvex to plumply 3–4-angled (not com-pressed, not winged, epidermes usually corky, often tuberculate)
Sphagneticola
24. Some or all cypselae winged (each bordered by wing of membranous or corky tissue different from that of body of cypsela)
→ 25
24. Cypselae sometimes sharp-edged (not winged)
→ 27
25. Heads in glomerules or borne singly (sessile or subsessile in axils); cypselaewinged (rays, not discs, wings lacerate)
Synedrella
25. Heads borne singly or in corymbiform, dichasiiform, or paniculiform arrays (not sessile); cypselae winged (rays and discs, wings not lacerate)
→ 26
26. Phyllaries 9–30 in 1–4 series (outer 2–5 similar to others, unlike foliage); pappi of 2(–3) persistent (often aristate or subulate) scales without additional scales
Verbesina
26. Phyllaries 26–38+ in 3–4+ series (outer 2–6+ similar to foliage in shape, texture, and indument); pappi of 2–3 fragile or persistent awns or subulate scales plus 2–8+, distinct or basally connate, erose or lacerate scales (often each cypsela with additional seta on inner shoulder)
Jefea
27. Cypselae 3–4-angled (weakly or not at all compressed or obcompressed, epidermes usually thick, corky)
→ 28
27. Cypselae (all or at least disc) strongly compressed or obcompressed or flattened (epidermes seldom thick and corky)
→ 30
28. Corollas white or whitish (paleae linear-filiform, not conduplicate)
Eclipta
28. Corollas yellow to orange (paleae lanceolate to ovate, conduplicate)
→ 29
29. Leaves elliptic, linear, oblanceolate, obovate, or ovate, glabrous or puberulent to villous and/or sericeous (outer phyllaries elliptic, oblanceolate, or ovate)
Borrichia
29. Leaves lanceolate to lance-linear, sparsely scabrous (outer phyllaries lance-linear to linear)
Pascalia
30. Annuals or perennials (mostly 5–30+ cm; larger leaves mostly 1–5+ cm); involucres 3–8 mm diam.; phyllaries 5 in 1(–2) series, or 8–15+ in 1–3 series
→ 31
30. Perennials (coarse, 10–150 cm; larger leaves mostly 5–25 cm); involucres 10–30 mm diam.; phyllaries 12–35 in 2–5 series
→ 32
31. Disc florets 25–100(–200+); receptacles conic; cypselae ellipsoid to obovoid; pappi 0, or fragile, of 1–3 bristlelike awns
Acmella
31. Disc florets 10–20; receptacles convex; cypselae cuneate; pappi of 2(–5+) stout awns
Calyptocarpus
32. Leaf blades oblanceolate to lanceolate or lance-linear (longer usually 8–25 cm), margins entire
Helianthella
32. Leaf blades rounded-deltate to ovate or lance-ovate (longer usually 5–8 cm),margins coarsely serrate
Lasianthaea
1. Perennials; leaves all or mostly basal
→ 2
1. Subshrubs or shrubs; leaves cauline
→ 3
2. Ray florets 20–40
E. scaposa
2. Ray florets 0 (heads nodding in fruit)
E. nutans
3. Ray florets 0
E. frutescens
3. Ray florets 8–25
→ 4
4. Heads in paniculiform arrays; leaves tomentose to strigose
→ 5
4. Heads borne singly; leaves glabrous or canescent, scabrous, and/or strigose (not tomentose)
→ 6
5. Leaves tomentose (branching among heads mainly distal; ray florets 11–21, corolla laminae 8–12 mm)
E. farinosa
5. Leaves tomentose to strigose (branching among heads mainly proximal; ray florets fewer and smaller)
frutescens (see 8 Encelia farinosa)
6. Leaves glabrous or glabrate; disc corollas brown (ray laminae lengths 1.5–2 times disc diams.)
E. californica
6. Leaves scabrous, strigose, and/or canescent; disc corollas yellow (ray laminae lengths 1–1.2 times disc diams.)
→ 7
7. Leaves scabrous to strigose (not canescent)
E. resinifera
7. Leaves canescent, sometimes strigose as well
→ 8
8. Leaves sparsely canescent and strigose; rays 11–21, laminae 8–15 mm (relatively deeply toothed)
E. virginensis
8. Leaves ± silvery-canescent (not strigose); rays 14–25, laminae 10–25 mm (relatively shallowly toothed)
E. actoni
Source FNA vol. 21, p. 64. FNA vol. 21, p. 118. Author: Curtis Clark.
Parent taxa Asteraceae > tribe Heliantheae Asteraceae > tribe Heliantheae > subtribe Ecliptinae
Subordinate taxa
Acmella, Agnorhiza, Balsamorhiza, Berlandiera, Borrichia, Calyptocarpus, Chrysogonum, Echinacea, Eclipta, Encelia, Enceliopsis, Engelmannia, Flourensia, Geraea, Helianthella, Heliopsis, Jefea, Lasianthaea, Lindheimera, Melanthera, Pascalia, Phoebanthus, Sanvitalia, Scabrethia, Silphium, Sphagneticola, Synedrella, Verbesina, Wedelia, Wyethia, Zinnia
E. actoni, E. californica, E. farinosa, E. frutescens, E. nutans, E. resinifera, E. scaposa, E. virginensis
Synonyms subtribe Enceliinae, subtribe Engelmanniinae, subtribe Spilanthinae, subtribe Verbesininae, subtribe Zinniinae
Name authority Lessing: Linnaea 6: 153. (1831) Adanson: Fam. Pl. 2: 128. (1763)
Web links